David Strathairn
— Reverend Bobby Paradise
Barbara Hershey
— Elizabeth Paradise
Kirk Acevedo
— Manny Marquez
Anita Barone
— Sammi
Vivienne Benesch
— Alison Paradise
Patrick John Flueger
— Luke Paradise
James Le Gros
— Matthew Paradise
Kiersten Warren
— Grace Paradise
Elaine Stritch
— Isabella
James Gammon
— Old Cowboy
Rick Hoffman
— Clark Cavanaugh
Shea Whigham
— Jeremiah Alcott
Richard T. Jones
— Senator Michael Linney
Haley Fife
— Susanna
Darryl Peterson
— XL
Anthony Leger
— Director