Cheyenne Jackson
— Eli Faisel
Anthony Rapp
— Logan Joyce
Jessica Richards
— Rose
Mitchell Jarvis
— Shakespeare / Janitor
Kelsey Carthew
— Simonia
Chasen Bauer
— Windsor Bisby
Nicole Tompkins
— Arden
Philip Labes
— Jay
Christopher Matias Aguila
— Terry
Marquis Wood
— Marcus Robertson
Camille Cregan
— Penny
Stacie Mitchell
— Keyla
Pamela Bowen
— Ms. Wilt
Harrison White
— Board President
Chuck Lines
— Tech Director
Thessa Mloe
— Techie #2
Dia Tequali
— Fairy #1
Dahlia Tequali
— Fairy #2
Baker Chase Powell
— Theseus
Maisie Klompus
— Hippolyta
Oscar Rodriguez
— Philostrate
Nick Zayas
— Quince
Ally Cron-DeVico
— Flute
Joey Luthman
— Lysander
Timmy Lee
— Demetrius
Kristen Corona
— Helena
Jennifer Newton
— Mother
Robert Paul Taylor
— Gym Teacher
Ricco Ross
— Mr. Robertson