Miriam Shor
— Stephanie
Sharon Houston
— Aimee
Adam Walden
— Can't Go Guy
Phe Caplan
Ethan Sandler
Kathryn Hahn
Stephanie Kurtzuba
Lucia Marano
Zach Galifianakis
— Pathetic Guy
Benjamin Byron Davis
— Zeius (Drag Queen)
Claudine Ohayon
Francesca Ferrara
— Holly
Randy Sklar
— Arguing Brother
Jason Sklar
— Arguing Brother
Dante Salerno
— DeNiro Fan
Mustapha Zagackney
— Volunteer Hugger
Fitz
— Non-Volunteer Hugger
Gabriel Harris
— Afraid of Germ Lady
Matt Price
— Guy with Secret
Jason Nash
— Secret Announcer