Jonathan Taylor Thomas
— Wesley Benfield
Mark Hamill
— Lamar N. Benfield
Judge Reinhold
— Robert Rigsbee
Ellen Burstyn
— Mattie Rigsbee
Gwen Verdon
— Alora
Harve Presnell
— Finner
Edward Herrmann
— Reverend Vernon
Gail O'Grady
— Elaine Rigsbee
Dana Ivey
— Beatrice Vernon
Jeff Kizer
— Deputy Hollins (as Jeff Kaiser)
Claudia MacLeod
— Young Mattie Rigsbee