Darren McGavin
— Timothy Donovan
Mickey Rooney
— Bailey
Shelley Fabares
— Grace Donovan
Murray Hamilton
— Henry Carpenter
Michael Conrad
— Silas Rumford
Ross Martin
— Mayor Stokes
Katy Kurtzman
— Jamie Carpenter
Brenda Scott
— Charity
Larry D. Mann
— Larson
John Crawford
— Thunder City Sheriff
Martin Kove
— Kelso
Larry Pennell
— Shepherd
James Chandler
— Ridgely
Joe Higgins
— Greenbush Sheriff
H.B. Haggerty
— Sharkey
James Almanzar
— 1st Horseman
Alvy Moore
— 2nd Horseman
David S. Cass Sr.
— Seaman Dodge
Richard Wright
— Seaman #2
Hugh Hooker
— Seaman #3
Don 'Red' Barry
— Sheriff at Stagecoach
Ralph Manza
— Lou
Hanna Landy
— Frieda
Dick Winslow
— Gambler #1
Warde Donovan
— Gambler #2
Ken Del Conte
— Jake
Wally K. Berns
— Man
Bob Minor
— Shotgun
Daryle Ann Lindley
— Lady at Ringside
David Mitchell
— 1st Ringsider