Carlos Alazraqui
— Charlie Evans
Dana Barron
— Kristy
Alfonso Freeman
— Pastor Kennedy
Pam Grier
— Zelda
Lou Diamond Phillips
— Garrett
Ellen Albertini Dow
— Natalie Shaw
Megan Ward
— Michelle
William Brent
— Additional Voices (voice, as Billy Unger)
Jacoby Shaddix
— Thomas Walker
Victor Browne
— Jack Chadway
Judea Cavoto
— Abby Taylor
Lynda Reynoso
— Maggie Walker
Rhett McKinney
— Roger
William Van Noland
— The Man
Laken Romine
— Young Natalie
Christopher Michael Holley
— Lieutenant Williams
Michael Alaimo
— Father Adams
Michael Alaimo
— Christina Genusu
Emily Frazier Klingensmith
— Mother
Fred Pitts
— Doctor
Susan Anderson
— Receptionist
Damien Xavier Johnson
— Dante
James Anthony Cotton
— Marty Fitzpatrick
Mary Mackey
— Hospital Administrator
Matthew Vlahakis
— Bank Representative
Duane Schirmer
— Book Store Manager
Peter Quartaroli
— ER Doctor
Jen Rainin
— ER Nurse (as Jennifer Rainin)
Christina A. Wood
— ER Nurse #2 / Demon Mother
Michael Greggans
— ER Doctor #2