John Beal
— Joel
Albert Dekker
— Longinus
Maurice Moscovitch
— Lamech
Marjorie Cooley
— Tamar
Ian Wolfe
— Tax Collector
Lloyd Corrigan
— Jemuel
Warren McCollum
— Zadok
Olaf Hytten
— Nathan
Marc Loebell
— Judas
Anthony Marlowe
— Singer
Lester Sharpe
— First Zealot
Harold Minjir
— Andrew
Earl Gunn
— Wounded Man
Albert Spehr
— Second Zealot
George Rosener
— Merchant
John Merton
— Under-Officer
Perry Ivins
— First Elder
D'Arcy Corrigan
— Blind Man
Max Davidson
— Old Man
Stanley Price
— Second Elder
Belle Mitchell
— Jemuel's Wife
Irving Pichel
— Jesus Christ (voice)
Rose Plumer
— Townswoman
Evelyn Selbie
— Townswoman
John Abbott
— Starving Beggar