May Robson
— Aunt Marcia Prentiss
Sybil Jason
— Abigail Prentiss
Guy Kibbee
— Asa Plunkett
Jane Bryan
— Betsy Ann Prentiss
Fred Lawrence
— Tom Squires
Dick Purcell
— George Chester
Mary Treen
— Libby, the Housekeeper
Gus Shy
— John 'Johnny' Shores, the Chauffeur
Maude Allen
— Mabel
Granville Bates
— Sheriff Pengast
Victor Potel
— Deputy Jake Hutchinson
George E. Stone
— Steve
Gordon Hart
— Mayor Bart Cabot
Tom Wilson
— Bill Brown
Robert Emmett Keane
— Mister Bridges, a Lawyer
Jack Wise
— Weymouth, the Hotel Desk Clerk
Joseph E. Bernard
— Courtroom Spectator
Hal Craig
— Motorcycle Policeman
Joseph Crehan
— Deputy Coroner Frank Knickerbocker
Joe Cunningham
— Jury Foreman
Lillian Harmer
— Mrs. Pengast
Stuart Holmes
— Juror
Anne O'Neal
— Flora, the Telephone Operator
Jessie Perry
— Juror
Jacqueline Saunders
— Juror
Leo White
— Juror