Ryan Scott Thomas
— Mr. Burke
D. Patrick Bauer
— Al (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams")
John Latchford Beck
— The Shopkeeper (as John Beck)
Leanna Chamish
— Paula (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales")
Mike Baldwin
— Carl (segment "Sleep When You're Undead")
Kelly Coston
— Janice (segment "Last Kill and Testament")
Lee Doll
— Dr. Weinberg (segment "Sleep When You're Undead")
AJ Hyde
— Patrick (segment "Sleep When You're Undead")
Shane Elliott
— Mummy
Fred Hahn
— Robert Marshall (segment "Last Kill and Testament")
Lindsay Hanson
— Victorian Vixen (segment "Sleep When You're Undead")
Jimmy George
— Benjamin Porter (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales")
Virginia House
— Susan Marshall (segment "Last Kill and Testament") (as Virginia Frank)
Mark J. Kilbane
— Roger (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales")
Chris LaMartina
— Dante (segment "Last Kill and Testament")
Mary Fay LaMartina
— Mother (segment "Sleep When You're Undead")
Justin Lanham
— Ghost (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams")
Sheldon Lawrence
— Professor Gauntheim (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales")
Cindy Marie Martin
— Nadine (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams")
Brian Fountain Murray
— Brady (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams")
Mary Jane Oelke
— Ms. Bennett (segment "A Picture's Worth a Thousand Screams")
Jess Owen
— Vampire (segment "Sleep When You're Undead")
Vince Saulsbury
— Vampire Expert (segment "Sleep When You're Undead")
Chris Stewart
— Story Heroine (segment "Dead Men Do Tell Tales")
George Stover
— Alan Marshall (segment "Last Kill and Testament")
Frank Vince
— Chazz Marshall (segment "Last Kill and Testament")
Bernie Wamhoff
— Milton (segment "Last Kill and Testament")
Myke Wells
— Terry (segment "Sleep When You're Undead")
Randi Williams
— Vampire Food (segment "Sleep When You're Undead")