Patrick Fugit
— Alex Buckingham
Jennifer Morrison
— Katherine Stern
Karen Gillan
— Lily
Aaron Staton
— Michael
Eddie Kaye Thomas
— Dave
Michael Nouri
— Rabbi Baskin
Gilles Marini
— Dr. Antonio Rosenblatt
Ryan O'Nan
— Gary
Elvy
— Anastasiya
Lesley-Anne Down
— Victoria
JoBeth Williams
— Mrs. Stern
Bob Gunton
— Mr. Stern
Michael Bachmann
— Blaine
Andre M. Johnson
— Vernon
Robert Towers
— Mohel
Julie Gonzalo
— Lara
Victoria Tennant
— Barbara
Phil Abrams
— Dentist
Tenille Houston
— Susan
Evan Arnold
— Doctor
Adam Kulbersh
— Fred
Dana Powell
— Holly
Scout Durwood
— Rhonda
Chase Ryan Jeffery
— Waiter
Vanessa Claire Stewart
— Carol
Knuckles
— Tucker
Holli Dean
— Maid of Honor