Stelio Savante
— Demas
Christopher Maleki
— Benyamin
Jonathan Roumie
— Jesus
Carmen Roman
— Mary Magdalene
Rula Sirhan Gardenier
— Mary
Hannah Godnik
— Young Mary
Leena Kurishingal
— Tikva
Richard Cotovsky
— Barabbas
Christian Castro
— Thaddeus
Glenn Stanton
— Roman Guard
Jacob Alexander
— Roman Guard
Phillip Edward Van Lear
— Roman Guard