Jim Fullington
— The Sandman
Rob Szatkowski
— Rob Van Dam
Jeremy Lynn
— Himself
Tom Laughlin
— Tommy Dreamer
Troy Martin
— Shane Douglas
Kevin Sullivan
— Himself
Peter Senerchia
— Taz/Tazmaniac
Charles Scaggs
— 2 Cold Scorpio
Dean Simon
— Dean Malenko
Ron Simmons
— Himself
Mike Durham
— Johnny Grunge
Ted Petty
— Rocco Rock
Terry Brunk
— Sabu
Eddie Guerrero
— Himself
Mick Foley
— Cactus Jack
Perry Satullo
— Saturn
George Caiazzo
— Kronus
Óscar Gutiérrez Rubio
— Rey Misterio Jr.
Al Poling
— 911
Scott Bigelow
— Bam Bam Bigelow
Chris Irvine
— Chris Jericho
Scott Levy
— Raven
Mark LoMonaco
— Buh Buh Ray Dudley
Devon Hughes
— D-Von Dudley
Michael Manna
— Big Stevie Cool
Terry Funk
— Himself
Lance Evers
— Lance Storm
Chris Candito
— Chris Candido
Yoshihiro Tajiri
— Himself
Matt Hyson
— Spike Dudley