Guy Madison
— Marshal James Butler 'Wild Bill' Hickok
Andy Devine
— Deputy Aloysius 'Jingles' P. Jones
Gloria Saunders
— Sally Brown
Lyle Talbot
— Blackburn
David Sharpe
— Johnny Powers
Zon Murray
— Carson
Robert Bice
— Dude
Jim Connell
— Pete
Fred Hoose
— Matt Thompson
Don Hayden
— Bob Ridgeway
Peggy Stewart
— Jane
Parke MacGregor
— Bennett
Fred Kohler Jr.
— Jordan
Tom Steele
— Barton
Michael Vallon
— Charlie Rogers