Anthony Michael Hall
— Johnny Smith
Nicole De Boer
— Sarah Bracknell Bannerman
Chris Bruno
— Sheriff Walt Bannerman
David Ogden Stiers
— Reverend Eugene 'Gene' Purdy
Kristen Dalton
— Dana Bright
Rick Tae
— Dr. Tran, Ph.D.
Anna Hagan
— Vera Smith
John L. Adams
— Bruce Lewis
Campbell Lane
— Barker #2
Tyler Williamson
— Diner Brother #1
Daniel Williamson
— Diner Brother #2