Scott Bigelow
— Himself
Nikita Breznikov
— Himself
Mick Foley
— Himself
Melissa Hiatt
— Herself
Roddy Piper
— Himself
Bruno Sammartino
— Himself
Louis Albano
Mohamed Ali
— Self (archive footage)
Edward Ellsworth Annis
Chris Candito
— Self (archive footage)
Troy Martin
— Shane Douglas
Mike Durham
— Johnny Grunge (archive footage)
Christopher Ford
— Devon Storm
Francine Meeks
David Heath
— Gangrel
Stan Hansen
Curt Hennig
— Mr. Perfect (archive footage)
Mike Hegstrand
— Road Warrior Hawk (archive footage)
Matthew Kaye
— Matt Stryker
Joe Laurinaitis
— Road Warrior Animal
Scott Levy
— Raven
Josip Peruzović
Ted Petty
— Rocco Rock (archive footage)
Balls Mahoney
Norman Smiley
David Smith
— Self (archive footage)
Kevin Sullivan
Trudy Vachon
— Luna Vachon
John Watson
— Mikey Whipwreck
Larry Zbyszko
— Larry Zbyszko