Sunah Bilsted
— Zoe Pendersen
Nathan Parsons
— Justin Tyme
Sarah Paulson
— Sarah Pendersen
Natasha Goss
— Olivia
Jayme Ratzer
— Barista
Seth Bailey
— Priest
Darren Capozzi
— Neighbor Sex Guy (voice)
Amanda Hendy
— Coffee Shop Patron
Annie Hendy
— Coffee Shop Patron
Robert Hubert
— Coffee Shop Patron
Brett McKenzie
— Coffee Shop Patron
Stacey Scowley
— Neighbor Sex Girl (voice)
Susan Suite
— Coffee Shop Patron