Christina Brucato
— Kitty Genovese
Michael Potts
— Archibald Smith
Maria Dizzia
— Mary Cunningham
Jamie Harrold
— Bob Cunningham
Thomas Kopache
— George Bernstein
Adrian Martinez
— Gonzales
Samira Wiley
— Joyce Smith
Lucy Martin
— Florel Bernstein
Don Puglisi
— Sam
Mario Israel
— Winston Moseley
Sophia Lillis
— Debbie Bernstein
Evan Fine
— Billy Cunningham
Booch O'Connell
— School Girl #1