Karen Gillan
— Rachel Milligan (segment 'Conventional')
Matthew Cardarople
— Stu Mac 1 (segment 'Conventional')
James Ransone
— Stu Mac 3 (segment 'Conventional')
Tracie Thoms
— Tommy (segment 'Playing Dead')
Paul Telfer
— Reggie (segment 'Playing Dead')
Megan Duffy
— Melissa (segment 'Pinned')
Adi Shankar
— Dex (segment 'Playing Dead')
Ryan Turek
— Original Stu Mac (segment 'Conventional')
Diva Zappa
— Audience Member (segment 'Last Laugh')
Justin Gordon
— Evan (segment 'Pinned')
Mali Elfman
— Lisa (segment 'Perfect')
Lara Sebastian
— Emma (segment 'Conventional')
Amy Schloerb
— Audience Member (segment 'Last Laugh')
Michael May
— Stu Mac 2 (segment 'Conventional')
Trey Everett
— Josh (segment 'Perfect')
Jake Varta
— Joe (segment 'Playing Dead')
Andrew Furtado
— Corbin (segment 'The Great Corbin')
Skylar Roberge
— Grace (segment "Kill Them Mommy")
Kari Calhoun
— Devon (segment "Kill Them Mommy")
Hayley Crisp
— Dolores (segment "Kill Them Mommy")
Anthony Kirlew
— Malcolm (segment "Prey")
Lucas Champagne
— Ricky (segment "Prey")
Justin Mokayed
— Seth (segment "Prey")
Sam Uehling
— Jake (segment "Prey")
Josh Elliott
— Man (segment "Whispers")