Richard Ian Cox
— Donner
Jimmy Kimmel
— Skeezer
Mark Acheson
— Blitzen / Cupid / Santa
Mark Hildreth
— Dasher / Dancer
Nicole Oliver
— Prancer / Vixen
Scott McNeil
— Brock / Tubby / Elf DJ / Vocal Coach / Oiled Elf
John R. Taylor
— Comet
Tabitha St. Germain
— Noelle / Ele Kid / Gigi
Philip Maurice Hayes
— Elf Boss / Parrot (credit only)