George Macready
— Cornelius
Lowell Gilmore
— Pontius Pilate
James Flavin
— Longinus
Morris Ankrum
— Peter
Virginia Wave
— Mary of Magdala
Robert Wilson
— Jesus Christ
Grandon Rhodes
— Eltheas
Tom Charlesworth
— Thomas
I. Stanford Jolley
— Dismas
James Griffith
— Caiaphas
Charles Wagenheim
— Eltheas' Friend