Tom Everett Scott
— Dave Holden
David Moscow
— Tom Holden
Cara Buono
— Rachel
David Lowery
— Billy
Denis O'Hare
— Father
Michael Kelly
— Frankie
Leo Burmester
— Judge Perkins
Tibor Feldman
— Dr. Harry Fields
James Murtaugh
— Chief Bascomb
Michael Angarano
— Young Tom
Peter Anthony Tambakis
— Young Dave
Ted Travelstead
— Gas Attendant
Marcia DeBonis
— Sara
Chris Cantwell
— Mr. Taylor
Andrew Van Dusen
— Convenience Store Clerk
Jefferson Taffet
— Young Store Clerk
Mella Fazzoli
— Timmy the Mechanic
Charle Landry
— Mike Sanel
Christopher Petrosino
— Store Clerk's Son
Jenni Gallagher
— Denise
Chris McGinn
— Woman in Store
Andrew Sikking
— Liquor Store Clerk
Louis Ludwig
— Elderly Clerk
John Lally
— Mr. Orton
Trudy Lally
— Mrs. Orton
Gary Kauffman
— Prosecutor
Pete 'Conan' Winebrake
— Defense Attorney
Daniel Prucell
— Boy at Sara's