Stu Klitsner
— Ernie Cranshaw
Afton Shepard
— Roxanne DeMarco
Herschel Zahnd
— Robert Dillinger
Eric Welch
— Harry Bennett
Chase Anderson
— Young Ernie Cranshaw
Katie Stewart
— Madelyn Winton
Lilly Stanley
— Jessie Winton
Chloe Dimako
— Maddy Cranshaw
Sarah East
— Dawn - Head Waitress
Mike Seely
— Papa Cranshaw
Corey McCauley
— Demon
Nathanael Taylor
— Craig - The Teen Ticketer