Donald Glover
— Jason Rogers
Aubrey Plaza
— Kelly Peters
Dominic Dierkes
— Charlie Day
D.C. Pierson
— Duncan Wheeler
Matt Walsh
— Jim
Glenn Kalison
— Robert
Peter Saati
— Leroy
Kay Cannon
— Destiny
Bobby Moynihan
— Jordy
John Lutz
— Frank
Robbie Sublett
— Ricky Appleman
Tom Shillue
— Alan McGinty
Ellie Kemper
— Jamie
Kevin Brown
— Bouncer
Dan Eckman
— Bread Squeezer
Will Hines
— Mr. Stevens
Meggie McFadden
— Cathy
Kristopher Kling
— Sam
Ben Schwartz
— Dougie's Buddy
Ron Simons
— Mr. Rogers
Nick Packard
— Dougie
Daphne Ciccarelle
— Brianna
Gregory Burke
— Football Player
Jon Daly
— Greg
Joe James
— Security Guard (uncredited)