Lee J. Cobb
— Zadok
James Griffith
— Judas Iscariot
Ralph Freud
— Caiaphas
Robert Wilson
— Jesus Christ
Mike Connors
— Andrew
Tyler McVey
— Peter
Toni Gerry
— Cloas
Joanne Dru
— Mary Magdalene
Everett Glass
— Annas
Lowell Gilmore
— Pontius Pilate
Anthony Warde
— Barabbas
Peter Whitney
— Nikator
John Stephenson
— John the Baptist
Barbara Billingsley
— Claudia - Wife of Pilate
George Sawaya
— James the Less
Robert Cornthwaite
— Simon the Zealot
Lawrence Dobkin
— Matthew
I. Stanford Jolley
— Simon the Pharisee
Renny McEvoy
— Dismas
Leonard Penn
— Pharisee
Richard Reeves
— Gestas
Keith Richards
— John
Rick Vallin
— James
Claudia Drake
— Martha
Charles Wagenheim
— Lazarus