Robert Livingston
— Stony Brooke
Ray Corrigan
— Tucson Smith
Max Terhune
— Lullaby Joslin
Jean Carmen
— Marion Warren
Kenneth Harlan
— Phineas T. Flagg
Sammy McKim
— Jimmy Warren
Burr Caruth
— Judge Jonathan Warren
Bob Walker
— Henchman Seth Williams
Jack Padjan
— Henchman Charles 'Duke' Madden
Allen Connor
— Henchman Reggie Allen
Horace B. Carpenter
— Joe Larkin
Jane Keckley
— Mathilda Larkin
Lou Fulton
— Elmer Twiddlebaum
Ed 'Oscar' Platt
— Master of Ceremonies
Jack Ingram
— Jed, a passerby
Robert McKenzie
— Haberdasher Sandy MacDonald
Jack Kirk
— Sheriff
Edward Peil Sr.
— Dam Engineer Rankin
Richard Beach
— Surveyor
Fred Burns
— Livery Stable Owner
Budd Buster
— Settler
Bob Card
— Settler
Wes Warner
— Settler
Silver Tip Baker
— Settler
Bud McClure
— Settler
Jack O'Shea
— Settler
Fred Parker
— Settler
Bob Burns
— Settler
William McCall
— Settler Flanagan
Lee Ford
— Settler Perkins, new father