Jeffrey Jarrett
— Himself
Steve Borden
— Sting
Allen Jones
— AJ Styles
Daniel Covell
— Christopher Daniels
Nelson Rodriguez Erazo
— Homicide
Shawn Hernandez
— Hernandez
Jason Reso
— Christian Cage
Terry Gerin
— Rhino
Brandon Silvestry
— Senshi
Josh Harter
— Chris Sabin
Jeremy Fritz
— Eric Young
Larry Zbyszko
— Larry Zbyszko
Nuufolau Joel Seanoa
— Samoa Joe
Scott Levy
— Raven
Chris Parks
— Abyss
Matt Hyson
— Brother Runt
James Cox
— James Storm
Chris Harris
— Himself
Mark LoMonaco
— Brother Ray
Devon Hughes
— Brother Devon
Brian James
— BG James
Monty Sopp
— Kip James
Chase Stevens
— Himself
Andy Douglas
— Himself
Daniel Solwold Jr.
— Austin Starr
Peter Williams III
— Himself
Norman Smiley
— Himself
Retesh Bhalla
— Sonjay Dutt
Zach Gowen
— Himself
Frank Gerdelman
— Kazarian