Jason Reso
— Christian
Nuufolau Joel Seanoa
— Samoa Joe
Steve Borden
— Sting
Chris Parks
— Abyss
Kurt Angle
— Himself
Scott Rechsteiner
— Scott Steiner
Allen Jones
— AJ Styles
Terry Gerin
— Rhino
Josh Harter
— Chris Sabin
Jeremy Lynn
— Jerry Lynn
Monty Sopp
— Kip James
Brian James
— B.G. James
Thomas Matera
— Antonio Thomas
Giovanni Roselli
— Romeo Roselli
Brandon Silvestry
— Senshi
Daniel Solwold Jr.
— The Austin Starr
James Cox
— "Cowboy" James Storm
Jacqueline Moore
— Jackie Moore
Peter Williams III
— Petey Williams
Gail Kim
— Gail Kim
Mark LoMonaco
— Brother Ray
Devon Hughes
— Brother Devon
Nelson Rodriguez Erazo
— Homicide
Shawn Hernandez
— Hernandez
Christy Hemme
— Christy Hemme (Valet)
Bob Backlund
— Mr. Bob Backlund (Ringside)
Charles Ashenoff
— Konnan (Ringside)
John Rodriguez
— Johnny Rodz (Ringside)