Kurt Angle
— Kurt Angle
Steve Borden
— Sting
Jamar Shipman
— "Black Machismo" Jay Lethal
Adam Jones
— Adam "Pacman" Jones
Ron Killings
— Ron Killings
Chris Parks
— Abyss
Nuufolau Joel Seanoa
— Samoa Joe
Jason Reso
— Christian Cage
Chris Harris
— "Wildcat" Chris Harris
Dustin Runnels
— Black Reign
Robert Roode Jr.
— Robert Roode
Frank Gerdelman
— Kaz
James Cox
— "Cowboy" James Storm
Terry Gerin
— Rhino
Allen Jones
— AJ Styles
Travis Tomko
— Tomko
Mark LoMonaco
— Brother Ray
Devon Hughes
— Brother Devon
Monty Sopp
— Kip James
Brian James
— BG James
Nelson Rodriguez Erazo
— Homicide
Shawn Hernandez
— Hernandez
Patrick Martin
— Alex Shelley
Josh Harter
— Chris Sabin
Lance Hoyt
— Lance Hoyt
James Guffey
— Jimmy Rave
Daniel Covell
— Christopher Daniels
Elix Skipper
— Elix Skipper
Brandon Silvestry
— Senshi
Scott Levy
— Raven