James Murray
— Judas
Jeremy Guskin
— Jesus
Ronney Ascher
— Manuel Hossenfeffer Rodriguez
Marti Cooney
— Mrs. Baker / Hoagie Woman
Laurence Frommer
— Mr. Baker
Elizabeth Wood
— Mary / Disgusted Angel
David Skigen
— Joseph
Sal Vulcano
— Lawn Mower Boy / Extra
Matthew Glass
— Larry
Hank Poje
— James Peterson / God / Smitty
Jonah Zeiger
— Vinny (as Jonah Zieger)
Kelley Rae O'Donnell
— Play Angel
David Hubbell
— Herbie Falafen
James P. Murray
— George
Lino Alvarez
— Dr. Puglia / Yelling Angel
Pete Barker
— Moses
Ken Dray
— Noah
Dennis Meehan
— Ham Slicing Boy
Hillary Ayn Ryan
— Sandy Weinberg (as Hillary Gouse)
Lyle Silversmith
— Max Weinberg
Jason Hom
— Ezekiel Weinberg
Jonathan Beatrice
— Scared Angel
Colin Liander
— Roman Centurion / Extra
Michael Rigby
— Roman Centurion
Patrick Nicholas
— Satan
Christopher Morgan
— Bar Wiping Boy
Bennato Pennella
— Bar Tender Assistant
Andrew Hanniffy
— Extra
Brian J. Jamieson
— Extra
Glenn Klein
— Extra