Steve Borden
— Sting
Rob Szatkowski
— Rob Van Dam
Joan Marie Laurer
— Chyna
Kurt Angle
— Himself
Jeffrey Jarrett
— Jeff Jarrett
Karen Jarrett
— Herself
Allen Jones
— AJ Styles
Tom Laughlin
— Tommy Dreamer
Chris Harris
— Himself
Matthew Hardy
— Matt Hardy
Robert Roode Jr.
— Bobby Roode
James Cox
— "Cowboy" James Storm
Chris Parks
— Abyss
Anthony Mayweather
— Crimson
Frank Gerdelman
— Kazarian
Matthew Massie
— Max Buck
Mickie James
— Mickie James
Ashley Lomberger
— Madison Rayne
Rob Strauss
— Robbie E.
Brian Kendrick
— Himself
Shawn Hernandez
— Hernandez
Matt Barela
— Anarquia
Shannon Moore
— Himself
Jesse Neal
— Himself
Thea Trinidad
— Rosita (Ringside)
Sarah Stock
— Sarita (Ringside)
Rebecca Treston
— Cookie (Ringside)