Hugh Dancy
— Nick
Liane Balaban
— Gabrielle
Mamie Gummer
— Stella
Benjamin Walker
— Andy
Michael Chernus
— Michael
Jonathan Gutierrez
— Hector
Ryann Shane
— Juliette
Jesse Stevenson
— Ian
Jasai Chase-Owens
— Frankie
Kathryn Faughnan
— Jen
Gillian Jacobs
— Zoe
Bill Camp
— Coach Buehl
Bess Wohl
— Gretchen
David Zayas
— Ramon
Laura Heisler
— Sandy
Patch Darragh
— Brian
Daniel Farcher
— Brute
James Biberi
— Ref
Gary Cherkassky
— Soccer Player #1
Christopher Clawson
— Bartender
Donato DeMarinis
— Opera Patron
Anna Kuchma
— Hooker