Terry Brunk
— Sabu
Rob Szatkowski
— Rob Van Dam
Brian Lee Harris
— "Prime Time" Brian Lee
Tom Laughlin
— Tommy Dreamer
Trisa Laughlin
— Beulah McGillicutty
Kristina Laum
— Kimona Wanalaya
Chris Irvine
— "Lionheart" Chris Jericho
Anthony Durante
— Chris Jericho
Francine Meeks
— Francine
Brian Knighton
— Axl Rotten
Don Haviland
— Hack Meyers
Samula Anoa'i
— Sammy The Silk
Matt Anoa'i
— Matty Smalls
Perry Satullo
— Perry Saturn
George Caiazzo
— John Kronus
Don Harris
— Himself
Ron Harris
— Himself
Jerome Young
— New Jack
Jamal Mustafa
— Mustafa Saed
Scott Levy
— Raven
Michael Manna
— Stevie Richards
Brian Heffron
— The Blue Meanie
Michael Bucci
— Super Nova
Terry Gordy
— Terry "Bamm Bamm" Gordy
Paul Varelans
— "Poler Bear" Paul Varelans
Peter Senerchia
— Taz
William Sierra
— Bill Alfonso
James Maritato
— Little Guido
John Smith
— J.T. Smith
Salvatore Bellomo
— "Wildman" Sal Bellomo