Samuel Alton Johnston
— Sami Callihan
Tommaso Whitney
— Tommaso Ciampa
Thomas Ballester
— AR Fox
Quinn Ojinnaka
— Moose
Davey Vega
— Himself
Mat Fitchett
— Himself
Joseph Robinson
— Juice Robinson
Aaron Frobel
— Michael Elgin
Fénix
— Himself
Pentagón Jr.
— Himself
Johnny Buck
— Buck Nasty
Devin Cutter
— Himself
Mason Cutter
— Himself
Dustin Howard
— Chuck Taylor
Scott Colton
— Colt Cabana
Christopher Dijak
— Donovan Dijak
Caleb Dewall
— Silas Young
Candice LeRae
— Candice LeRae
Jessica Cricks
— Jessicka Havok
Alex Daniels
— Alex Daniels
CJ Esparza
— Himself
Connor Braxton
— Himself
David Crist
— Dave Crist
Mark Pobanz
— Himself
Dori Prange
— Heidi Lovelace
Kimberly Ann Frankele
— Kimber Lee
Dan Barry
— Himself
Deveon Aikens
— Dezmond Xavier