Melissa Benoist
— Jennifer
Blake Jenner
— Billy Forsetti
Grant Harvey
— Mikey Valentino
Melissa Bolona
— Jules
Nick Eversman
— Greg Basualdo
Greg Germann
— Mr. Langdon
Jim Beaver
— Crabtree
Andre Royo
— Mr. Adams
Aramis Knight
— Carlos
Brad Hunt
— Frank
Blaine Saunders
— Young Girl
Cole Bernstein
— Miranda
Derek Mio
— Jimmy
Jack Fisher
— Young Billy
Marcus Brown
— Prison Guard
Jack Foley
— Boy
Julien Cesario
— Tattoo Artist
Brenda Bakke
— Margarette
Nathaniel Stroud
— Josh Adams
Sasha Morfaw
— Classmate
Rose Marie Brown
— Diner Patron
Jes Selane
— Jail Prisoner
Ramsay Philips
— Billy's Dad
Mark Schaefer
— Prison Guard #2