Pretty Bird

Billy Crudup

— Curtis Prentiss

Paul Giamatti

— Rick Honeycutt

Kristen Wiig

— Mandy Riddle

David Hornsby

— Kenny Owenby

Denis O'Hare

— Chuck Sutters

Elizabeth Marvel

— Tonya Honeycutt

Anna Camp

— Becca French

Aasif Mandvi

— Ted the Banker

Adam LeFevre

— Phil the Neighbor

Garret Dillahunt

— Carson Thrash

Daniel Stewart Sherman

— Ted the Credit Card Clerk

Daniel Talbott

— Hustler (uncredited)

James Wetzel

— Dennis

Brent King

— Berger

Lennon Parham

— Woman with Beef

Nate Mooney

— Randy Pendler

Dierdre Friel

— Erica the Waitress

John Behlmann

— Corporate Hotshot

Jordan Gelber

— Corporate Hotshot

Eisa Davis

— Corporate Hotshot

Sarah Uriarte Berry

— Corporate Hotshot

Michael Heintzman

— Money Guy

Robert Testut

— Jimmy

Paul Schneider

— Beach Dog Jogger (as Otto Peotomy)