Jay Baruchel
— Reed Fish
Alexis Bledel
— Kate
Victor Rasuk
— Frank Cortez
Schuyler Fisk
— Jill
A.J. Cook
— Theresa
Katey Sagal
— Maureen
Shiri Appleby
— Jill Cavanaugh
Chris Parnell
— Ralph
Valerie Azlynn
— Kate Peterson
DJ Qualls
— Andrew
Blake Clark
— Irv
Tommy Dewey
— Rex
Jim Cody Williams
— Cowboy
Boti Bliss
— Waitress
Rossif Sutherland
— Gabe
David Beggs
— Farmer
Jackie Benoit
— Imogene Sandstrom
Eugene Smith
— Preacher
Reed Fish
— John Penner
Peter Alwazzan
— Radio Show Caller (voice)
Scott Laster
— Floyd Fish (voice)
Todd Fjelsted
— Bartender (uncredited)