Aaron Tveit
— Thomas 'Tommy' Reilly
Edy Ganem
— Alejandra 'Allie' Batista
Lou Diamond Phillips
— Monsignor Renzulli
Gregory Alan Williams
— Judge Watford
Yohance Myles
— Willis 'Silk' Thompkins
Spence Maughon
— Vick Vargas
Lauren Helling
— Jane
John Newberg
— Kent Dunbar
David Joseph Martinez
— Mario Batista
Cynthia Huerta
— Salma Batista
Lauren Compton
— Nikki
Jeanne Caldarera
— Sister Jean
Jo-Ann Robinson
— Louisa Reilly
Ladson Deyne
— Father John
George Sanchez
— Cardinal Sierra
Mikki Val
— Betty
Susan LaBrecque
— Dr. Sylvia Touran
Thada Catalon
— Juror
Ketrick "Jazz" Copeland
— Bailiff
Joshua Powell
— Photographer
Camryn Jones
— Samantha
Stephanie Hearn Purcell
— Reporter
J.W. Smith
— Apartment Manager
Catherine Kim Poon
— Nurse
Reginald Mack
— Body Guard #1
Gary Lee
— Body Guard #2
Charles Adams
— Protester / Courtroom Guest / Couple (uncredited)
Anthony Barbier
— Courthouse Cop (uncredited)
Chad Governale
— Detective (uncredited)
Victoria Hardway
— Protester / Courtroom Guest / Couple (uncredited)