The Late Bloomer

Johnny Simmons

— Dr. Peter Newmans

Brittany Snow

— Michelle

J.K. Simmons

— James Newmans

Jane Lynch

— Caroline

Maria Bello

— Brenda Newmans

Beck Bennett

— Luke

Kumail Nanjiani

— Rich

Paul Wesley

— Charlie

Charlotte McKinney

— Attractive Woman

Ken Marino

— Mr. Hanson

Matt Jones

— Max

Illeana Douglas

— Linda

Laraine Newman

— Noema Willcoxen

Brian Doyle-Murray

— Stagehand

Joey Greer

— Doug

Lenora Crichlow

— Nikki

Vanessa Ragland

— Jenny

Bobby Flay

— Himself

Sam Robards

— Dr. Lawson

Blake Cooper

— Josh

Roxanna Dunlop

— Montana

Lauren Shaw

— Rosalyn

Nathan Cooper

— Host

Tara Grant

— Tinder Girl #3