Robert Pattinson
— Samuel Alabaster
Mia Wasikowska
— Penelope
David Zellner
— Parson Henry
Nathan Zellner
— Rufus Cornell
Joseph Billingiere
— Zachariah Running Bear
Robert Forster
— Old Preacher
Morgan Lund
— Bar Creep
David Wingo
— Barrel of Laughs
Russell Mael
— Prairie Crooner
Gabriel Casdorph
— Anton Cornell
Ray Kelleher
— Barkeep
Gary Brookins
— Sheriff
Landon Weeks
— Piano Player
Larry Zeng
— Scalped Traveler
Sabrina Chappuis
— Angry Traveler
Palmer Scott
— Barber
Luana Zellner
— Bell Maiden
Ronald Zellner
— Photographer
Deanna Milsap
— Bathhouse Madam
Angela Summers
— Hostess Matilda
Fenton Quinn
— Wagon Driver
Josh Lambert
— Musician (uncredited)
Toto Miranda
— Musician (uncredited)
Yvonne Lambert
— Musician (uncredited)
Lauren Gurgiolo
— Musician (uncredited)