James Franco
— Homer Barron
Amy Smart
Topher Grace
Alicia Witt
Marianna Palka
— Emily Grierson
Beth Grant
Zackary Arthur
— Quentin
Sky Azure Van Vliet
— Elly
Xosha Roquemore
— Young Tabitha
Janet Wood
— Angie
Michael Chieffo
— Mr. Grierson
Carmela Corbett
— Olivia
Molly Berg
— Rebecca
Caroline Hebert
— Constance
Leslie L. Miller
— Nancy
Ace Gibson
— Jesus
Sam Morgan
— Tom
Karsen Liotta
— Young Emily
Mark Slater
— Mr. Stovall
Toby Grey
— Jason Compson
Elayn J. Taylor
— Tabitha
Terra Wellington
— Elly's Aunt
Casey Kramer
— Agatha
Diane Adair
— Elly's Mother
David Lee Hess
— Soldier
John Knox
— Elly's Father
Laura Parker
— McLendon's Wife
Sonya Wallace
— Dilsey
Dennis Renard
— Will Mayes
Ronan MacRory
— Augustus Bunce