Alex R. Wagner
— Dave
Rachel Shapiro
— Kiley
Caleb Fortune
— Martin
Corinne Natyshak
— Erica
Dorie Casper
— Erica
T.C. Matherne
— New Years Guy
Will F Young
— New York Friend
David Drake
— Brian
Gianna Spiega
— Mackenzie
Shayna Beining
— Haley
Jenna Larson
— Carri
Anne Downey Trussell
— Amanda
Sean White
— Steve
Bridget Flaherty
— Crazy Katie
Allison Taylor
— Allison
Gabby Perrea
— New Years Girl
Kevin Wozniak
— Marshal
Rebecca Dooley
— New York Girl
Becky Lang
— March Girl