Brave New Jersey

Tony Hale

— Clark Hill

Anna Camp

— Peg Prickett

Raymond J. Barry

— Captain Ambrose P. Collins

Erika Alexander

— Helen Holbrook

Evan Jonigkeit

— Sparky

Heather Burns

— Lorraine Davison

Sam Jaeger

— Paul Davison

Matt Oberg

— Chardy Edwards

Mel Rodriguez

— Sheriff Dandy

Dan Bakkedahl

— Reverend Ray Rogers

Grace Kaufman

— Ann Davison

Sandra Ellis Lafferty

— Old Farmer Lady

Leonard Earl Howze

— Stan Holbrook

Noah Lomax

— Peter

Blaque Fowler

— Old Timer

Adina Galupa

— Shannon

Jack Landry

— Neighbor Del

Bill Coelius

— Mac

Roy Hawkins Jr.

— Rugged Farmer

Helen Ingebritsen

— Woman with Flashlight

Kathy Winchell

— Panicked Woman

Antoinette Cancelliere

— Karen

Ricky Bobby

— Rugged Farmer

Patrick Miller

— Mr. Pepper

Michael Dowling

— Father

Gabriel Landis

— Jimmy

Harp Sandman

— Ziggy

Bruce Boone

— Townsperson