John P. McGinty
— Aaron
Preston Sadleir
— Ben
Maleni Chaitoo
— Ananya
Sydney Morton
— Allie
Joshua Castille
— Michael
Garrett Zuercher
— Steven
Craig Fogel
— Jeff
Melissa Golliday
— Sapphire
Tony Sheldon
— Ben's Father
Jennifer Smith
— Ben's Mother
Benjamin Mapp
— Dominic
Matthew Bauman
— Realtor
Scott Bixby
— Grindr Guy
Peregrine Heard
— Waitress
Marti Gould Cummings
— Drag Queen
Jarvis Derrell
— Friend In Bar
Madeline Trumble
— Office Worker