What if...

Kevin Sorbo

— Ben Walker

Kristy Swanson

— Wendy Walker

John Ratzenberger

— Mike the Angel

Debby Ryan

— Kimberly Walker

Kristin Minter

— Cynthia

Toni Trucks

— Claire

Taylor Groothuis

— Megan Walker

Stelio Savante

— Joel Muller

Kevin Yon

— Charlie

Grant James

— Henryk Zimmerman

Brittany Risner

— Brittney

Suzanne Lang

— Front Desk Nurse

Liam Matthews

— Night Nurse

Danielle Hoetmer

— Elaine

Dallas Jenkins

— Gas Station Attendant

Richard Pierre-Louis

— Guardian Angel

Tom McElroy

— James McCutcheon

Thomas Flannery Jr.

— Carl

Preston Mulligan

— Dylan

Dennis Lee Kelly

— Ross Bessette

Brad Heller

— Ross Bessette Jr.

Russell Wolfe

— Car Salesman

James Daniels

— Obnoxious Husband

Sharon M. Hayes

— Obnoxious Woman

Maya Jenkins

— Young Kimberly

Mary Thornton

— Bus Station Announcer (voice)

Abbie Finner

— Girl in Church (uncredited)

Madison Hertel

— Party Attendee (uncredited)

Daniel James Wrzesinski

— Bus Station Employee (uncredited)