Elena Nikitina Bick
— Dinah
Chris Conner
— Jake
Jennifer Gareis
— Sarah
Greg Wood
— Grandfather
Noah Headley
— Steven
Accalia Quintana
— Michaela
Alex Yurcaba
— Jacob
Jack Buckley
— Amos
Hannah Close
— Young Sarah
Elena Talan
— Washer Woman
Hayden Saunier
— Dour Amish Woman
Peter Patrikios
— Elroy Dwyer
Zoe Bournelis
— Mrs. Dwyer
Lexy Rutt
— Dwyer Girl
Chase Rippon
— Dwyer Boy
Amy Morse
— Amish Woman
Ruth Peebles
— Marriage Counselor
Markus Zanders
— Jacob's Father
Brian Shenko
— Amish Boy
Kerry Shultz
— Red Lady