Samantha Smedley
— Teodora Castelucci
Tyler Ankenman
— Palmer
Emily Ryan Reed
— Shannon
Sarah Sumner
— Yara
Andres De Vengoechea
— Dan
Augustus Wilson
— Ryan
Jennifer Suter
— Caroline Maloney
Alyssa Accardo
— Shelby
Alexandra Simota
— Katherine Muffburn
Rachael Feldman
— Scout
Shaun Kennedy
— Noah
Christina Cappelli
— Ruthie
Omar Pelaez
— Tiki
Amy Stringer
— Aubrey
Zack Abramowitz
— John-A-Ton
Peter Fiorentino
— Yung Taco
Jarrod Allan
— Hamlit
Robert Molinari
— Teddy's Dad
Andrew Gonzalez
— Victor
Francesca Redeye
— GiGi
Brittini Schreiber
— Billie
Alexandra Noland
— Becca
Alex McKelley
— Leigh
Pedro Villalta
— Cameron
Trent Stone
— God (voice)
Jaine Ye
— Lauren
Eli Cox
— Michael
Dawn Aneada
— Polly
Hannah Abney
— Casting Director