Callan Wilson
— Paul Douglas
Glenn Tucker
— Abraham Maslow
Jeff Rose
— Steven Douglas
Rich Swingle
— Micah Maslow
Joyce Swingle
— Hava Maslow
Cassady McClincy-Zhang
— Sarah
Donna Botts
— Dorothy Douglas
Abbey Kochman
— Rebecca Maslow
Donald James Parker
— David Maslow
Seth Adair
— God (voice)
Lynda Stein
— Rachel Maslow
David Vandergriff
— Pastor
David Ross
— Rabbi
Bob Cleeland
— Deprogrammer
Paul Spite
— Messianic rabbi
John Grabeel
— Train passenger
Tony Caudill
— Plumber
Keegan Martion
— Butch
Gavin Martion
— Larry
Zander Shores
— Tom
Houston Vandergriff
— Houston
Kaitlin Borst
— German girl in concentration camp (voice)
Courtney Lee Simpson
— Congregation member (uncredited)