Jeremy Irons
— Atticus
Jack Huston
— Adam
Mamie Gummer
— Annabelle
Megalyn Echikunwoke
— Clementine
Ben Schwartz
— Jimmy
Will Patton
— Wisdom
Poorna Jagannathan
— Dr. Fisher
Frankie Faison
— Deacon Frank Dodge
Catherine Dyer
— Dorothea
Colby Minifie
— Danielle
Owen Harn
— Arnold
Larry Pine
— Jack Dorner
Whitney Goin
— Adela Dodge
Julia Valentine Larson
— Julia
Inder Kumar
— Doctor Kumar
Danielle Lyn
— Nicole
Alexandra Ficken
— Amanda
Monica Edelhoff
— Natalie
Timothy Nichols
— William
Liz McGeever
— Liz
Cory Scott Allen
— Mark Keane
Jeff Campanella
— Lance
Kai N. Ture
— Eliza Dodge