An Ordinary Killer

DJ Perry

— Detective Lynn Kendall

Terence Knox

— Detective Ben Bannister

Dan Haggerty

— Detective James LeBaron

Terry Jernigan

— Detective David Sheridan

Charles Matthau

— Detective Mark Peyton

Christopher Nendick

— Detective Steve Hersh

Joshua R. Pyne

— Randy Bledsoe

Laura Slater

— Katherine Agnew

Alanna Thompson

— Dee McGuire

Curtis Hall

— Dan McGuire, Jr.

Marti Bowling

— Rose Renker

Joey Albright

— Dale Barber

James Bonadio

— Paul Powell

David Borowicz

— Larry Taylor

Scott Reschke

— Jerry Conway

Dean Teaster

— Dan McGuire, Sr.

Leonard J. Krawczyk II

— Bartender Jerry Bates

Randall Godwin

— Quincy Hall

Leonard J. Krawczyk

— Mr. Schmidt the Jeweler

Bradley M. Egen

— Richard Loynes

Dennis Haskins

— Ronald Smith

Patricia Hammond

— Elaine Smith

Zack Sztanyo

— Boy Who Finds Body

Ian Griffin

— Jim Jamison

Marty Bufalini

— Pathologist

Patrick Kelly

— Billy Winston

Audrey Bird

— Detective Geri Van Noord

Greg Mason

— John Smith

Jerry Stanecki

— Gary Watson

Jeffery Stetson

— DNA Lab Tech