Robert Goulet
— Billy Bigelow
Mary Grover
— Julie Jordan
Pernell Roberts
— Jigger Craigin
Marlyn Mason
— Carrie Pipperidge
Charles Ruggles
— The Starkeeper / Dr. Selden
Michael F. Blake
— (as Michael Blake)
Jack DeLon
— Mr. Snow
Linda Moulton Howe
— Louise
Patricia Neway
— Cousin Nettie (Nettie Fowler)
Marge Redmond
— Mrs. Mullin
Jim Taylor
— Dancer